vegan pizza at Coletta

Best Kosher Pizza at Coletta New York

When it comes to pleasing a crowd, there’s no better option than a fresh, steaming hot pizza. For an inclusive menu that ensures your dinner has something for everyone, take advantage of these kosher pizza recipes, inspired by Coletta in New York City!

While certified-kosher recipes require help from trained professionals, you can rest assured your guests will appreciate these easy, delicious kosher options inspired by Coletta’s own uniquely vegan menu. 

Coletta’s professional chefs have been trained in everything vegan and kosher, guaranteeing an inclusive dining experience you won’t soon forget. For more inspiration, check out our full menu or place an order to go. 

Unforgettable Kosher Pizza Recipes

Kosher Pizza Recipes at Coletta

The key to elevating your homemade pizza to truly unforgettable levels lies in one secret: quality ingredients. As you shop around, take the extra time to invest in fresh, locally sourced herbs and veggies. 

At Coletta, we set our pizza apart with homemade crust and marinara. Bring the same homey quality to your own meal! Check out our easy guide to making the perfect easy vegan pizza dough. 


Start by collecting your ingredients: fresh crust, tomato sauce, basil, olive oil, salt, and chunks of “mozzarella.” 

This classic is a breeze to make. Simply spread your sauce in an even layer across the surface of your crust, sprinkle a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil, and begin carefully layering your pizza with “mozzarella” and fresh basil leaves. Don’t feel too much pressure to cover the entire surface of your pizza with toppings; with this classic, less is actually more. Ideally, you should still see plenty of red sauce between the bright green leaves and white “mozzarella.” 

From here, simply sprinkle a pinch of kosher salt to bring out the brightness of the flavors, and enjoy!

Another perk of this classic is the ease with which you can personalize it to your own tastes. Try a drizzle of balsamic vinegar, additional herbs, or diced garlic for a fresh take on this age-old meal. At Coletta, an extra sprinkling of toasted pine nuts adds a mildly nutty flavor to the finished product. 

Margherita at Coletta

Classic “Pepperoni”

This classic is nearly as easy as the Margherita. Take the same ingredients list as before, simply adding vegan “pepperoni” to the mix. Exchange the basil for fresh oregano. This herb adds a savory intensity to your dish that perfectly complements the sharp, salty “pepperoni.” Make the pizza as before, layer your desired amount of savory “pepperoni” slices, and enjoy!

Rather than using whole chunks, try running the “mozzarella” for this pizza through a food processor first, allowing it to more evenly spread over the surface. 

Wild Mushroom Pizza

While everyone loves a classic, there’s something to be said for a little extra love. Savory, salty, and perfectly seasoned, this filling wild mushroom pizza is guaranteed to be the talk of your party. 

Start by gathering your ingredients: wild mushrooms, truffle oil, cipollini onions, creamy “ricotta,” fresh rosemary, and crema.

Start by cooking all the veggie ingredients. In doing so, you remove excess moisture that might otherwise lead to a soggy crust. At Coletta, we sear our wild mushrooms and take the extra time to fully caramelize our onions to a sweet finish. 

Next, drizzle your oil across the surface of a lightly toasted crust. From here, add your “ricotta,” fresh rosemary, and crema. Sprinkle caramelized onions and wild mushrooms over the surface of your pizza, then bake in your oven at 475 degrees Fahrenheit until fully cooked. All that is left is to enjoy!

Help from the Experts

Wild Mushroom Pizza at Coletta

For an even easier night in, call on the experts at Coletta! 

Every pizza at Coletta is fired to a delicious toasty finish in our custom-made brick oven. You’ll taste the difference in every bite as you dive into each crispy chew. The high temperatures and constant circulation of air ensure that every topping is cooked instantly, allowing for the greatest flavor and nutrition. 

In addition to the classics, enjoy creative offerings like:

  • Fig jam and “prosciutto” pizza, with a burst of fresh figs, homemade jam, “prosciutto,” baby arugula, evoo, “parmesan,” and a drizzle of aged balsamic
  • Buffalo chick’n pizza, topped with buttermilk fried chick’n, buffalo sauce, shaved celery, and blue “cheese” crema


Place an order for pickup or delivery today, or treat yourself to a truly special dining experience! Join us at our new Gramercy Park location to enjoy your meal in our professionally designed, vintage-inspired dining room.